Best Overall
FINETONES Fluted Buffet Cabinet
- Finish: Green, fluted doors
- Storage: 3 drawers, 4 doors, adjustable shelves
- Assembly: Two people recommended
- Overall Dimensions: 15.7"D x 55.1"W x 34.3"H
Pros
- Counter-height top makes serving comfortable
- Three drawers plus adjustable shelves
- Feels solid once assembled
- Wide 55-inch serving surface
Cons
- Long assembly that wants two people
The number that matters here is 34.3 inches. That's the height of the serving top, and it puts this cabinet at the same working height as a kitchen counter — you reach the back of it without stooping, and a hot dish goes down rather than out. The 55- and 58-inch cabinets we also recommend sit at 29.5 and 31 inches, which is table height. At a dinner party that difference turns into an ache by dessert.
The storage is the other half of the case, and it's laid out the way a buffet actually gets used: three drawers across the top for cutlery, napkins and candles, and four doors below opening onto adjustable shelves that take a stack of dinner plates plus a row of bowls. Adjustability earns its keep more than it sounds — a fixed shelf that fits plates won't fit a soup tureen. It's also the most solid of the flat-pack cabinets we recommend once it's standing; nothing about it feels provisional when the drawers are full.
Getting there is the work. This is a large flat-pack with a lot of parts and the instructions call for two people, so plan an afternoon and a second set of hands for standing the carcass up. Build it on cardboard, get it level on the floor before you load anything, and leave the door adjustment until last.
You also need 55 inches of wall and a 15.7-inch depth that keeps the walkway behind the table usable. In a tighter room, the SICOTAS or the REHOOPEX covers the small-wall case. On a wall that fits, the sage green and the fluted fronts are the version we keep coming back to.