Best Overall
Roundhill Prato 6-Piece Set
- Seating: 4 cross-back chairs plus a 52-inch bench
- Materials: MDF top with pine veneer; solid rubberwood base
- Set Weight: 198.6 lb
- Table Size: 68 x 38 x 30 inches
Pros
- Longest table here at 68 x 38 inches
- Solid rubberwood chairs and bench
- Seats six with room for serving dishes
- Upholstered seats with welt trim
Cons
- Veneer top marks without mats and pads
- Highest price in this group
Sixty-eight inches is what separates the Prato from everything else here. The top is longer and deeper than the 60 by 36 inch tables most of this group uses, and that extra strip in the middle is where serving dishes, a bread basket and a jug of water actually live during dinner. In a dining room, that space is the difference between a table you eat off and a table you serve from.
We keep coming back to this one because it is built like a dining table first and a package deal second. The base, the four cross-back chairs and the bench are solid rubberwood rather than veneered panels, the seats are upholstered with a welt-trim edge, and the distressed oak top sits on a pine-veneered core that keeps the price from running away entirely. It is also the highest-rated set on this page, which lines up with how settled it feels when you lean on a corner.
Two details worth knowing before it arrives. The top has a distressed texture, which looks lovely under a lamp and does catch crumbs in the grain, so a wipe after dinner beats an occasional polish. And the bench is 52 inches of backless seating: it tucks under the table when the room needs to breathe, and it is better for children and casual meals than for the head of a holiday table.
The real caveats are price and the veneer. This is the most expensive set here by a wide margin, and the top will mark if you drag stoneware across it, so put felt pads under the centerpiece and a trivet under hot dishes from day one. Assembly comes in several boxes and takes two people an afternoon; tighten the chair bolts again after the first week, a step the instructions do not emphasize.