Best Overall
Mxtxmy Extendable Round Oval Table
- Diameter: 43.3 inches
- Extended Length: 59 inches
- Seating Capacity: 4 to 8
- Tabletop Thickness: 1.18 inches
Pros
- Extends from four seats to eight
- Storage shelf in the base
- Cross base with a thick 1.18-inch top
- Smooth, quiet extension rail
Cons
- MDF veneer can chip at the edges
The extension is the whole idea, so it's where we started: the top opens, a leaf drops into the middle, and a 43.3-inch circle becomes a 59-inch oval. Close it back up and you have a round table again, which is the difference between a table that only works on holidays and one you eat at on a Tuesday.
That trick is why we recommend it for most households. Four seats with the leaf out, eight with it in, and a cross-shaped base that leaves enough legroom underneath for chairs to tuck away properly instead of sitting out in the walkway. The top is 1.18 inches of MDF in a walnut finish, and the shelf in the base is 20.55 inches wide, which is room for a stack of dinner plates and the serving bowl that never has a home.
Sturdiness is where an extending table usually gives itself away, because there's a joint in the one place you don't want one. This one weighs 103.6 pounds and sits on a cross base rather than four spindly legs, and in use the extension felt solid under a hand pressed to the middle rather than springy.
Plan the build for two people and an afternoon: the box is heavy, and the base, shelf, and rail all have to line up before the top goes on. After that it's a table you stop thinking about, which is the highest compliment a dining table can get.