Best Overall
East West Dublin 42-Inch Drop Leaf Table
- Base: Pedestal
- Seats: 4 open, 2 with leaves down
- Material: Solid Asian hardwood
- Open Size: 42"D x 42"W x 29.5"H
Pros
- Solid hardwood top and leaves
- 42-inch round seats four with serving room
- Pedestal leaves chair room on every side
- Leaves drop to a two-person top
Cons
- Linen White is a warm cream, not bright white
A pedestal base is the reason the Dublin sits at the top of this list. With no corner legs, chairs pull in from any side, and nobody at a small kitchen table has a leg to straddle. Both leaves drop, so the table goes from a two-person surface pushed against a wall to a 42-inch round that takes four plates, a salad bowl and a couple of elbows.
The top is solid Asian hardwood, not the veneered board several picks here use, and the finish has a depth the printed surfaces don't. Against the rest of this set, sturdiness is one of its stronger showings: the leaves sit level when they're up, and the pedestal doesn't walk when someone leans on the edge to stand. Assembly takes the usual hour with two people, and the base has to be squared before you tighten the top bolts or the table rocks.
What it doesn't do is disappear. With both leaves down it's still a table standing in the middle of the floor, where the Ashley below folds to a 27.75-inch console against the wall. For a kitchen where the table lives against a wall and comes out for dinner, that's the trade; for one where it stays out, it costs you nothing.