Best Overall
Raynesys 24-Inch Counter Stools
- Set Size: Set of 2
- Seat Height: 24 inches
- Seat Material: Bonded leather
- Weight Capacity: 400 lb
Pros
- Padded 17.7-inch saddle seat wipes clean
- 400-pound capacity, the highest in this group
- Slides under a 36-inch counter overhang
- Lowest-priced padded pair here
Cons
- Backless, so no back support
- Sold only as a pair
Twenty-four inches of seat height is the number that decides most island purchases, and these Raynesys stools land right on it. That leaves the 9 to 11 inches of clearance a 36-inch counter wants, so your knees clear the overhang and your elbows reach the countertop instead of floating above it. That fit, a padded seat and the lowest price of any padded pair in this group are what make them our top pick. If your island is the usual 36 inches and you need two seats, this is the pair to buy.
The seat is what sold us. It is a 17.7-inch saddle, noticeably wider than the 12-inch metal pans on the stackable sets here, covered in bonded leather over foam that gives a little without collapsing into the frame. Heavier steel tube than the budget norm is how it earns a 400-pound rating, the highest here. Spills wipe off with a damp cloth, which matters more in a kitchen than any of us like to admit.
Assembly is a short bolt-together job with the hardware in the box, and the shallow 13.4-inch depth is the quiet advantage: they slide most of the way under an overhang when dinner is over, so a small kitchen keeps its walking space. Black frame, black seat, nothing that competes with your cabinetry.