Best Overall
Amazon Basics Round Storage Ottoman
- Storage: Concealed compartment
- Upholstery: Button-tufted linen
- Load Rating: 300 lb
- Footprint And Height: 20"D x 20"W x 17"H
Pros
- Seat height lines up with sofa cushions
- 300-pound frame makes it a real seat
- Hidden storage takes blankets and toys
- Light enough to slide out of the way
Cons
- Dry-clean-only linen cover
- Tufted top is dimpled, not tray-flat
Seventeen inches is the number that earns this one its place. That is roughly where most sofa and chair cushions sit, so the top meets your heels instead of leaving your legs dangling, and the 20-inch diameter is wide enough for two pairs of feet. A wood frame rated to 300 pounds means it steps in as a spare seat when the room fills up, and the round shape moves through a tight room more gracefully than a rectangular bench.
The lid lifts off to a concealed compartment that takes a folded throw, a stack of magazines or the toys that never quite get put away, which is the sort of storage that keeps a small living room from looking like a small living room. Button tufting is what sells it for us: it reads as upholstery rather than a box with a cushion dropped on top. The linen-inspired cover is neutral but runs warmer and greyer than a pure beige, so compare it against a cream sofa before you commit.
Two things to know. The care label says dry clean only, which is an odd instruction for something feet land on every night; a vacuum and a lint brush handle the routine, but a coffee spill is not a wipe-and-forget. The tufting also leaves a slightly dimpled surface, so a tray wants a board underneath. At just under ten pounds, though, it slides aside with one foot when the kids want floor space, which is more than a solid coffee table can manage.