Best Overall
Kohler Frameless Medicine Cabinet
- Shelves: 2 adjustable tempered glass
- Material: Anodized aluminum
- Weight Capacity: 50 lb
- Dimensions (D X W X H): 4.81"D x 20"W x 26"H
Pros
- Mirror on the door front, back and interior
- Aluminum body resists damp bathroom air
- Two adjustable tempered-glass shelves
- Recessed or surface mounting
Cons
- Shallow shelf depth won't take tall bottles upright
Most medicine cabinets hand you a mirror that disappears the moment the door swings open. This Kohler keeps it. The door is mirrored front and back, the inside of the case is mirrored too, and the result is a usable reflection whether you are reaching past a half-open door or standing behind one that is wide open. In a small bathroom, that turns one door into several reflective surfaces doing the work of one.
It is the sort of detail we notice after a week of mornings, and the rest of the case backs it up. The body is anodized aluminum rather than engineered wood, so there is no painted edge to lift and no particleboard to swell in a steamy room, and the two tempered-glass shelves adjust on their brackets. It carries a 50-pound rating, which is generous for toiletries and even for the odd bottle of cleaning spray.
Installation is the other half of the argument. It can drop into the wall cavity between studs or hang on the surface, and the frameless beveled door sits flush either way. Recessed, it adds nothing to a narrow room; surface-mounted, it needs a level and a second pair of hands instead of a hole in the drywall. That flexibility is why this is the cabinet we put at the top of the list — it suits bathrooms we have not seen.
What you give up is warmth. Anodized aluminum reads clean and modern rather than furniture, and against beadboard or a painted vanity it will look like the practical object it is. On the wall of a primary bathroom, that is a fair trade for a cabinet with nothing in it that can warp.