Best Overall
VASAGLE Storage Bench 39.4"
- Finish: Cloud white
- Dimensions: 15.7"D x 39.4"W x 18.3"H
- Safety Hinges: 2
- Seat Capacity: 300 lb
Pros
- 300-pound seat rating
- Two support hinges hold the lid at any angle
- 39.4-inch width seats three children
- Cut-out side handles for moving it
Cons
- Not water resistant; wipe with a dry cloth
We sat on the VASAGLE before we filled it, because a bench in a playroom becomes a seat, a stage, and a step stool within a week of arriving. The 300-pound rating took two adults without a complaint from the frame, and the pair of support hinges means the lid parks at whatever angle you leave it, so it never comes down on a small hand reaching for a dinosaur.
At 39.4 inches wide and 15.7 inches deep, this is the shape we want in most playrooms. Three children can crowd the front of it at once, and the 18.1-inch seat height is right for perching while they dig. The cut-out handles at each end earn their keep too: a loaded bench is miserable to drag, and the slots give you somewhere to grip when the room gets rearranged for the fourth time this month.
What it is not is a toy organizer with cubbies. The inside is one long open box, fine for the big stuff and hopeless for the small: figurines, cars, and puzzle pieces sink to the bottom under everything else unless you stand a couple of open bins inside to act as drawers. It is also one bin deep, so the contents live in a single layer rather than a stack.
Particleboard under a white laminate is the honest caveat here. This is a flat-pack box, not hardwood, and it will show scuffs at shin height within a season. We make that trade happily, because the bench disappears under the job it does, and the finish is the last thing anyone notices once it is full.