Best Overall
Poofieotto Round Pouf Ottoman
- Care: Wipe clean
- Fill: One-piece high-density foam
- Size: 20" x 20" x 14"
- Cover: Plush fiber
Pros
- Molded foam core resists lumps
- 20 x 14 inches suits most sofa heights
- Wipe-clean cover with zippers
- Range of colors beyond the orange
Cons
- Ships compressed; up to 72 hours to expand
Almost every pouf in this category is stuffed with shredded foam, and that's the whole problem with the category: the chunks migrate, the top goes uneven, and you spend the life of the thing punching it back into shape. This one is a single molded block of high-density foam under a plush cover, and that construction is why it's our top pick. There is nothing inside to shift.
The dimensions do the rest of the work. Twenty inches across and 14 inches tall puts the top just below the seat of a typical sofa, so your heels rest instead of dangling, and there's room for both feet. The cover is plush fiber over a suede-like base with zippers, and it wipes clean with a damp cloth rather than demanding a wash cycle — an advantage in a room where drinks and muddy paws live. Burnt orange is a statement; the pouf comes in other colors, so choose with your room in mind.
It's a footrest first. The foam gives under a seated adult, which is exactly right under a pair of ankles and less right under a guest at a party — for that, the Fabulcozy in this group is the one with a base built for sitting. Set it in front of the couch and it will look the same in a year as it does the week it arrives.