Best Overall
Poofieotto Pouf Ottoman
- Fill: All-in-one foam core
- Weight: 5 lb
- Cover Care: Wipe with damp cloth
- Dimensions: 20"D x 20"W x 14"H
Pros
- 20-inch top fits both feet side by side
- Solid foam core holds its shape
- Five pounds, easy to drag with a foot
Cons
- Needs up to 72 hours to expand
- Cover is wipe-clean only
A 20-inch face over a solid foam core is the combination that made this our default. At 14 inches tall it lines up with the seat of an ordinary sofa, so feet land flat instead of sliding off a slope, and because the fill is one piece rather than a bag of beads, the top stays where you left it when you swing your legs up.
The cover has a nap that reads warmer than the flat knits here, and the color range is broad enough to let the room lead. What we paid attention to was the base: faux suede with zips, which grips a wood floor better than the slick knit covers on this list, so a 5-pound pouf doesn't skitter every time you stand up.
Two things to plan around. It arrives vacuum-packed and needs up to 72 hours to reach its full height, and the foam keeps firming for about a week after that, so day one is not the pouf you'll own. The other is its job description: this is a footrest rather than a chair. Put your full weight on it and you sink further than you expect, so don't buy it as the extra seat for a party.
Twenty inches turns out to be the useful number — wide enough for both feet side by side, narrow enough to slot between the sofa and the wall. We moved it from a reading chair to a desk and back without thinking about it, which is not something you can say about the 10-pound cubes in this guide.