Best Overall
VASAGLE Kitchen Island
- Shelves: 3 open shelves
- Max Load: 66 lb
- Materials: Steel frame, particleboard top
- Dimensions (D X W X H): 23.6"D x 47.2"W x 35.4"H
Pros
- Deepest top among the mid-size islands
- Three full-width shelves hold appliances
- Easiest build of the full-size islands
Cons
- 66-pound total load limit
- No drawers and no casters
Twenty-three and a half inches of depth is what turns this into a worktop rather than a shelf, and it is the reason the VASAGLE takes the top spot. Most of the islands here stop between 15 and 18 inches deep, which is fine for a coffee machine and not enough to stand at with a cutting board that isn't hanging off the front edge. This one gives you 47.2 inches of width at 35.4 inches high, which is counter height, so it slots against a wall or beside a run of cabinets as though it belonged there.
The three shelves underneath run the full width of the frame, which is more useful than it sounds: a toaster oven, a stack of bakeware and a box of dry goods all fit without being piled on each other. Steel legs and a particleboard top, adjustable feet that take out the wobble on an uneven floor, and the smoothest assembly of the full-size islands in this group, with the tool included.
What it isn't is a cart, and it doesn't hide anything. There are no casters and no drawers, so you are committing the floor space permanently and your clutter stays visible. Give the top a once-over for scuffs and dents before you start building — particleboard does not sand out, and a marked top is much easier to swap before the frame is standing.